Let's start with Harry Potter

Back

 

Even this short extract from Harry Potter contains spellings which cause challenges to reading and writing (reading and writing problems often overlap), as well as some pointless complications. If this extract were dictated to you, not only you, but many adults would be hard pressed to spell every word correctly.
 

  
   

"He scanned the starry sky for a sign of Hedwig, perhaps soaring back to him with a dead mouse dangling from her beak, expecting praise. Gazing absently over the rooftops, it was a few seconds before Harry realised what he was seeing.

     Silhouetted against the golden moon, and growing larger every moment, was a large, strangely lop-sided creature, and was flapping in Harrys direction. He stood quite still, watching it sink lower and lower. For a split second, he hesitated, his hand on the window-latch, wondering whether to slam it shut, but then the bizarre creature soared over one of the streetlamps of Privet Drive, and realising what it was, leapt aside.

     Through the window soared three owls, two of them holding up the third, which appeared to be unconscious."
 

  
 

The problems are due to the fact that nearly all 96 English spelling patterns (or 'rules') have some exceptions. So the question is, which irregularities should be tackled first since it would be near impossible to fix all irregularities in one go. Do you want to have a crack at deciding which problems should be tackled first? (So that you don't have to re-invent the wheel, we have pinpointed some of the most problematic reading and spelling problems below.)

  
       
    3 of the most problematic areas of spelling are:  
 

   1)

 The overlap between spellings for the ee  and  e sounds (e.g. feet, heat, these, field, weird, police, wet) and the many graphemes used for these sounds which have different pronunciations in other words.  For example:  
   

      feet    -   wet  (these are easy to read and write and could be called 'regular')
 

     BUT ea, e-e,  ie,  i-e,  eo,  ey,  i,  ay have different pronunciations:

     heat  -   great, heather, heart  

     these -   seven, there

     field  -  friend, tried, alien

     weird    veil, height, heifer  

      we    -  the
     police  - device, service

     people - leopard, leotard

     key    - they

      ski    - play

      quay  - play

       ski   - hi!

  
 

2) 

 The overlap between  ou, u, o, o-e and oo sounds. For example:  
   

 

       count  -  country - soup

      how                 spoon - blood - wood

      low                                   would

      go                    do                      woman - women - won

       both   -  bother - other  /  cut  - put

     boat   -  board

     home  -  come

    
 

3) 

 Missing and unnecessary doubled consonants, and unnecessary -e endings. For example:  
    The main doubling pattern which changes the vowel sound before it. (As in  he sat in the diner eating his dinner, while his tiny coffeepot made a tinny sound boiling on the hotplate'.) Many words such as tune and tunnel follow this pattern,  BUT the following don't:  
   

 

 mineral       arrive    arrange

  (miner)      (arise)    (derange)

      
   
And here are some unnecessary  -e endings:
 have,deliberate,are,gone		  
         
     


Our questions to you are:
 - Which of these main reading and spelling difficulties should we solve first?
 - Which words do you think use the patterns sensibly and which dont?
- Should we just bring the rogues into line by 'regularising' the words that don't conform to the patterns? (If so, what's most urgently needed)?

Send your opinions to Mashabell@aol.com